Thursday, November 13, 2008

Tamilnadu and Cinema !

Theories on political mobilization talk of how political actors garner support for themselves by playing on the identities of the people . Some , use racial identities . Others use language , religion , geography and many more ! I want to add one more to their exhaustive list . The identities that cinema stars create for themselves in the minds of the people. Tamilnadu is one classic example of how this has been done repeatedly and with stupendous success. There have been other cases all over India ( N.T.Ramarao , Rajkumar , Shathrughan Sinha , Govinda) and even elsewhere in the world . Why , even the United States was not spared ( Remember President Reagan ?? ) But , in Tamilnadu , the pattern seems to be repeating itself again and again ! First it was M.Karunanidhi , then M.G.Ramachandran ( MGR ) followed by J.Jayalaltiha , then Vijakanth and now the Superstar , Rajinikanth , for the nth time , is considering jumping into the political fray !

Cinema stars in Tamilnadu have had the uncanny ability to reach out to the common man. In times , where he has lost all hope in the system , they have been able to create a virtual universe where they question the evils of the Indian system such as corruption , dishonesty , unscrupulousness of the politicians etc on his behalf . They have been able to do on screen what the "aam aadmi" has always wanted to do . Bash the baddies and create utopia where the whole world lives in harmony and happiness. In doing this , they create so much goodwill in the minds of the audience that it is tempting to assume that the stars really mean what they say on screen.
Audience, here , is not an illiterate audience that lacks the ability to discern between the good and the bad . But , an educated urban audience that seems to consciously make this choice . This makes it even more puzzling ! Just google Rajnikanth and you will be surprised to find the innumerable number of blogs that celebrate the arrival of the Superstar into politics. At one point , it is these individuals who complain about the lack of people with the right capacities in positions of importance within the state and at the other we have the same people heralding Rajni as the saviour of Tamilnadu. What they fail to realize is that the system has not changed , only the actors have changed.

Does Rajnikanth really have the political acumen that the complicated nature of Tamilnadu politics demands ? Does he really have the credentials that could support his claim for the highest office in the state ? Doe he have the experience to shoulder the immense responsibility that the position demands ? How much ever hard I try , the answer to these questions are all on the negative. But the people of Tamilnadu , in their quest for change , for the emergence of the choice between Jaya and Karunanidhi have now zeroed in on this man who has no record of any political experience and whose whims and fancies are far more unstable than that of a pampered adolescent .

My sincere to advice to Mr.Rajnikanth is to please stay away from politics . We have enough problems to think of and we don't need him adding to our woes. If he really wants to enter the political arena let him first demonstrate his competence , through other means , rather than throwing out empty promises ! Let him create institutions that show they are capable of bringing the much desired change to the administrative change that the Tamilnadu system needs. If he succeeds , we would all be more than happy to see him in office !

5 comments:

Nivi said...

"Does Rajnikanth really have the political acumen that the complicated nature of Tamilnadu politics demands ? Does he really have the credentials that could support his claim for the highest office in the state ? Doe he have the experience to shoulder the immense responsibility that the position demands ?"

I cannot agree with you more. I dont think he does. Being a hard core, maybe a fanatical Rajini movie fan, i still do not think, he would make a good politician.

But let us look at it objectively.

Why Rajni will be a bad politician?
- His inability in making decisions, we have seen this "n" number of times. The whole, will i enter politics, will I not has honestly let people exasperated. Now its come to a stage where people are apathetic to those comments. Its like "Dude please dont waste our time, if you want to come, be our guest, else forget it, we dont want to waste any more print space on you"!

- He has not been totally on one side too. He sways here and there. Sometimes its supporting J, sometimes K.

-He seems to a guy who does well in guidance, not someone who can take serious action. Even his directorial debut Valli, failed. He somehow gives me an impression that cannot steer a ship safely

Why will he be not so bad?

-CHANGE!
People are sick and i mean sick of these two govt's in TN. In my opinion he has the necessary charm.power to garner votes atleast the first time around. i am sure of it

MGR was not a great mind too. He y himself infact would have been a poor administrator. What made MGR's reign truly one of the best periods in TN's history was the fact that he ackowledged he dint know much and surrounded himself with educated people for policy making. If rajini can do that, i dont think he will be too bad.

I do not buy the experience thing too much, cause K is almost a century old himself and still has not done anything great for the country.

In all probabilities, I think Rajini is better than Vijayakanth and SArathKumar! Imagine they coming to power.

If he does decide to content , he needs to do 2 things,

Be a strong person who stands by what he says

Surround himself with educated people and rise above partisan politics!

There you go, my 2 cents

Unknown said...

Nivi , Thanks for reading through the post ! You are probably the only person who checked the blog after I put it up on my status ! :-)

Alright , now let's get to our discussion which is indeed a good one considering both of us are die-hard fans of Rajni and both of us are now taking opposite stances on this issue.

I completely agree with everything that you have said in your post. But, my contention is , is it even possible at this stage in time to rise above partisan politics in Tamilnadu ? The political structure by itself is still immature. It is not going to let him function the way he wants to. Neither does he have the capacity to maneuver himself through this maze.

Let's assume Rajni starts a party. Who will be the members of his party ? Who will be the workers at the grass root level ? Probably some of his fans , but , you will more or less see numerous defections at the lower levels of other parties to Rajni's party. These are not people who are in the political arena to look after the State and ensure its welfare. They are there for a reason , in pure self-interest. Can Rajni balance his noble intentions and the political aspirations of his party members ? That brings us to the comparison with MGR ! If the Puratchi Thalaivar could do it , can't our Superstar ?

Now although MGR came to power with an agenda for development he still used his "dravidian" identity ( his ideological affiliation with Anna and the DMK ) to garner the support of his followers . He even declined the Padmashree when it was awarded to him because the wording was in Hindi. This was in addition to his overwhelming popularity with the people.

MGR had a command over his followers that I am sure would be difficult for Rajni to muster . I am of this opinion , because his partymen would be more educated and aware in comparison to the gullible people of the sixties whom MGR had to lead. There was this unquestionable faith in him. So much was the support that he won hands down in the election in Pudukottai when he was away in America for his treatment. I am not sure if Rajni can recreate that kind of magic. His popularity seems to pulsate between ups and lows . He after all needed a Chandramukhi and a Shivaji to put him back on the popularity track ! The pundits had already written him off after Baba ! In politics you dont have the luxury of hiding behind a bad movie. People are not going to be happy if they realise you are not doing what they voted you to do.

Nevertheless, If Rajni really manages to be a strong person , surrond himself with educated people and rise above partisan politics like you said and still manages to pull it off , I will vote for him in the subsequent assembly election ! Until then , its wait and watch for me !

Nivi said...

Its amazing how we agree and yet dont.

Here is where I agree. Can Rajini do it as easily as MGR or NTR did ? No way
Reasons, like you point out
a. Ppl dont think of Rajini as God, like they really did with NTR and MGR.

b. MGR decided he is going to be in politics early on and was actively campaigning theough his movies.

We all the know the subtelities in his songs and movies. The numerous references to udhaya suriyan. He had campaigned nearly 10 years or more before he actively plunged in to politics. Has Rajini done that, Nope.

Will he rise above partisan politics, the religion and caste based politics. He might. Why? Because his parties agenda will not be like that of DMK ( so called Dravidian but really Anti-Brahmin). Lets not get in to DMK's merits, that will be a topic on its own.
Or like PMK- the pro dalit. But will be a party that promises change and welfare for TN. A TN that is being increasingly subject to moral policing by goondas turned politicans turned moral police. A TN that needs some serious face lift in terms of law and order. And I think he can do it.

Please not the use of "can". He can do it but will he do it is the big question. Rajini somehow does not strike me as a strong, level headed, confident politician. Will he be able to show the finger to other asses like Cho does. Does he have the courage to stand up to these havoc creating nobodies, I am really not sure. He really has to prove himself as a leader that people can trust before he hopes to win the election.
The last thing we need is a chief minister who oscillates and wants to please everyone. If only she was not so whimsical JJ would be the best thing to have happened to TN.Will be able to be as cocky as her or Modi and stick to his decisions and policies, I am really not sure. But I am sure as hell willing to give change a chance.

With DMK soon gonna split after the grandmaster kicks his bucket, and the other small guys like Sarath, Captain, PMK and Vaicko ( if he ever gets out of prison) there is pretty much a divided TN. If he cannot use this time and moblize people towards him, I am not sure if he ever can.

But personally it would a great loss for me. It would be the loss of a star and rise of a probably average politician!

I can only think how apt it would have been if Rajini indeed did Mudhalvan. I can imagine him saying

"Enyayum arasiyalvadhiya akiteengale"

Madhu said...

Very true, Aravind. A good man does not necessarily make a good politician! And that too, in a country like ours.. it's better he stays away, for his own good and ours!!

passion@itsbEsT said...

An interesting discussion between two hardcore thalaivar fans! i agree with nivi and think he can win.. but i hope he doesn't get into politics. sorry, but i don't want the tamilnadu-cinema connection to continue :)